Address: 363 Tonetta Lake Rd, Brewster, NY 10509
When: Sat, Sep 12 – Sun, Sep 13
Categories: Furniture, Clothing, Toys & Kids
Huge Garage Sale! Sept 12 & 13 10AM-3PM Tons of designer bags & shoes, clothes, toys, furniture, holiday decor & SO MUCH MORE!
How to shop a yard sale in Brewster
Yard and garage sales in Brewster, NY run hottest Saturday morning between 7 a.m. and 10 a.m. Multi-family and neighborhood sales typically have better volume than single-family sales — Yardy flags both. Carry small bills, a reusable tote, and patience for haggling: $5 on a $20 tag is normal, $1 on a $2 paperback usually is not.
Pricing rule of thumb across the Southeast: kids' clothing $0.50-$2 per item, books $0.25-$1, mid-century furniture $20-$150, kitchenware $1-$5. If a host's prices feel high, come back at noon — most yard sellers would rather discount than haul leftovers back inside. For larger pickups (sofas, appliances) bring a truck and a friend; cash in hand often unlocks "just take it" pricing on bulky pieces.
More sales in Brewster, NY
- Brewster, NY Estate Auction at a Beautiful Peach Lake Home · Auction · Thu, Sep 10
- Brewster, Ny Estate Auction At A Beautiful Peach Lake Home (213 photos) · Auction · Thu, Sep 10
- Starr Ridge Manor Moving Sale (451 photos) · Estate · Fri, Sep 11
- Starr Ridge Manor Moving Sale · Estate · Fri, Sep 11
- Starr Ridge Manor Moving Sale · Estate · Sat, Sep 12
Browse all yards in Brewster
Yardy guides for sale shoppers
About Yardy
Yardy is a local one-time-sale search engine for the Southeast US. We aggregate estate sales, yard sales, garage sales, neighborhood pop-ups, and short-window auctions from 20+ sources — no permanent storefronts, no thrift-store clutter. Each listing here is cross-referenced against our duplicate-detection system so you see the cleanest version of a sale even when it's posted in three different places.
Buying secondhand keeps usable goods out of landfill and circulates cash to neighbors instead of national chains. The average Southeast estate sale diverts 500-2,000 lbs of household goods from disposal; a busy Saturday on Yardy moves an estimated 8-12 tons across our coverage area. Browse the 2026 State of Southeast Secondhand report for the full data set.